In a move that has ignited controversy, former U.S. President Donald Trump shared an AI-generated image of himself dressed as the pope on his Truth Social platform. The post, later reposted by the White House, came just days before the Vatican conclave to elect a new pontiff—and during the official mourning period for Pope Francis, who passed away on April 21 .
While Trump’s supporters dismissed it as humor, Catholic leaders and Italian politicians slammed the image as disrespectful and offensive. Here’s why this post stirred such strong reactions.
1. The Controversial AI Image
The digitally altered photo shows Trump in papal vestments—a white cassock and pointed miter—raising his finger in a gesture reminiscent of papal blessings. The image was posted just as cardinals prepared for the solemn conclave to choose Francis’ successor .
“This wasn’t just a joke—it was a tone-deaf move during a sacred moment for Catholics.”
2. Catholic Leaders React with Fury
The New York State Catholic Conference, representing U.S. bishops, called the post a “mockery” of the Church’s mourning period.
“We just buried our beloved Pope Francis, and the cardinals are about to elect a new successor. Do not mock us.”
In Italy, former Prime Minister Matteo Renzi accused Trump of “clowning around” while the world mourned. Even the Vatican, though silent, reportedly found the post in poor taste .
3. Trump’s Defense & Supporters’ Reactions
The White House defended Trump, stating he had “paid respects” at Francis’ funeral. Far-right commentator Jack Posobiec shrugged it off, saying, “It’s called a sense of humor.”
Meanwhile, Sen. Lindsey Graham jokingly endorsed Trump for pope, tweeting: “Watching for white smoke… Trump MMXXVIII!”
“If Trump was aiming for laughs, he missed the mark—badly.”
4. Why the Timing Made It Worse
The post landed during the nine-day mourning period, a time of deep reflection for Catholics. With the conclave set for May 7, many saw the stunt as undermining the Church’s solemn process .
“Imagine cracking jokes at a funeral—that’s essentially what Trump did.”
5. What This Reveals About Trump’s Strategy
This isn’t the first time Trump has used provocative imagery to dominate headlines. But the backlash suggests even his base might question the tactical wisdom of mocking a global religious institution.
“Love him or hate him, Trump knows how to stay in the spotlight—even if it means alienating millions of Catholics.”
Final Thoughts
While Trump’s supporters may see this as harmless fun, the outrage from Catholic leaders and Italian media shows that religious sensitivity still matters. With the conclave days away, this incident could further strain Trump’s already tense relationship with the Vatican.
